For many agency owners and staff, the most stressful ADRs are the ones tied to insulin injections. These patients often need care once, twice, or even three times a day. That adds up to costly claims, and Medicare auditors know it. We’ve seen these cases more commonly flagged. And when they are, your agency needs to prove the care was necessary.
The problem? Even when nurses document well, charts can fall short of showing the bigger picture, especially around medical necessity. This gap leads to denials, lost revenue, and endless frustration.
That’s where social workers come in. They bring a unique ability to validate medical necessity by documenting caregiver unavailability, patient inability and by painting the homebound picture, adding credibility to your clinical notes. Their role can be the difference between approval and denial when auditors scrutinize your claims.
At The Home Health Consultant, we’ve seen this first-hand countless times. As our co-founder Mariam Treystman explains:
“If you want to pass an ADR, ADR preparation begins at the first visit.”
This article will show you how social workers can help prove medical necessity, why their documentation matters, and tips for how to integrate them into your process to protect both your patients and your agency.
*This article was written in consultation with Mariam Treystman.
***Important Note: Mariam is not a clinician. What we share here comes from years of observing ADR trends with agencies, not from offering medical advice. Any use of social workers in this context should be directed by your agency’s clinical staff, based on medical necessity for the individual patient, and their unique care needs. Each case requires documentation of need and a clear attempt to find alternative caregivers to take over insulin injections.
What Does Medical Necessity Mean in Home Health?
Before we can understand the role of social workers, we need to ground ourselves in what medical necessity actually means. Medicare doesn’t simply ask, “Does the patient need care?” Medicare asks, “Does the patient need skilled care that cannot be provided by anyone else?”
In simple terms, medical necessity means the services provided are reasonable AND necessary to treat the patient’s illness or injury. For Medicare-covered home health, it requires proving:
- The patient cannot safely perform the task on their own.
- No available or willing caregiver can perform the task.
- The ongoing need for skilled intervention is clearly documented at each visit.
For a more in-depth breakdown of eligibility criteria and what determines medical necessity, check out the article below.
For insulin injections, this standard can be especially tough to meet. It’s not enough to say a patient has diabetes.
You must paint the picture: Explain why the patient cannot self-inject and why no family member, friend, or neighbor can reliably help.
Understanding this foundation helps explain why insulin injections are so frequently flagged by auditors.
Why Are Insulin Injection Cases in Home Health So Closely Scrutinized?
Insulin injection cases put agencies in the spotlight because of their cost. A nurse visiting daily, or sometimes multiple times per day, for months creates a very expensive claim for Medicare. Once agencies reach a certain visit minimum, any additional visits get paid per diem. This is called an outlier payment.
To prevent abuse of this system, CMS has limited the amount of outlier payments agencies can receive. Auditors know this, and they want to see airtight proof that each visit is justified.
That means every visit must reestablish:
- Eligibility (is the patient still homebound?)
- Ongoing Need (why can’t they inject themselves today?)
- Caregiver Situation (who else could help and why they cannot?)
Without consistent answers to those questions, ADR denials are almost inevitable.
Because of this heightened scrutiny, we’ve seen agencies often need more than just nursing notes to validate necessity. That’s where social workers can become a critical part of the documentation chain.
How Can Social Workers Help Validate Medical Necessity in Home Health?
When the stakes are high, social workers bring an additional layer of credibility. Their evaluations can confirm details that a nurse’s note alone may not cover, creating a stronger picture of necessity.
As our co-founder Mariam Treystman explains:
“In cases where caregiver availability could be a gray area, I've seen a lot of agencies send out a social worker every episode. The social worker will evaluate whether there’s a family member or other caregiver who can replace the clinician and the agency.
This can validate medical necessity, because if there is no other caregiver available, for that specific injection, at that specific time, your agency needs to be there. Having the social worker assess for this is going to be additional backup and proof for a potential ADR down the line.”
Basically, there is a “this, then that” order to verifying medical necessity for insulin injection patients. Once a clinician and social worker have confirmed that the patient is unable and there are not family members or caretakers able or willing to administer the injections, the medical necessity is verified.
The process of trying to find a family member or caregiver to take over the injections should occur at least once per episode. This is where social workers can help agencies back up nursing documentation.
***Of course, this approach only works when clinically appropriate. Agencies should not assume that sending a social worker automatically proves necessity. The social worker visit itself must also meet Medicare’s requirement for medical necessity.
Patients lacking this support often also need community resources. A social worker visit can be the bridge, helping set up those services so the patient isn’t left without support long-term.
That means the social worker should evaluate real barriers, attempt to identify alternatives that could be trained, and connect patients with community services when possible. Blanket use of social workers for all diabetic patients may backfire if auditors view it as a convenience rather than a justified need.
What Common Scenarios Prove Insulin Injection Medical Necessity in Home Health?
To see this role in action, consider a few common scenarios:
- A patient lives with family, but caregivers work during the day and cannot provide morning injections.
- A patient has poor vision, tremors, or memory loss that make blood sugar checks and self-injection unsafe.
- A patient has no family or community support at all, and social worker notes confirm this.
In each case, the nurse may note the barrier, but the social worker can provide full context. Without this additional documentation, auditors may assume the service was a matter of convenience rather than true necessity.
These scenarios show how social workers can help transform gray areas into clear evidence that stands up to ADR review.
How Does Social Worker Input Strengthen ADR Defenses?
When auditors review charts, they’re looking for consistency, credibility, and context. Social worker documentation strengthens all three.
- Reduces Denials: By clearly documenting the absence of a caregiver, it’s harder for auditors to argue services are unnecessary.
- Shows Compliance with Medicare’s Intent: Home health isn’t meant for “forever patients.” Social worker notes prove the agency is attempting to discharge the patient to the community once they find a safe alternative.
- Provides Consistency with OASIS Data: As Mariam Treystman explains,
“In a patient’s OASIS, you have to mark who they live with. That's part of the assessment that gets submitted to Medicare. So they could live with a whole family, but that family could be out of the house before the patient wakes up. Unless you're painting that picture, you're not getting approved on your ADR. Part of painting that picture is having a second set of eyes to also validate this.”
The social worker’s perspective helps connect the dots between the OASIS, the nursing notes, and the broader story of medical necessity.
How Should Agencies Incorporate Social Workers Into This Process?
Knowing the value social workers bring, the next step is making their involvement intentional rather than incidental.
Agencies can strengthen both compliance and care by:
- Building social worker evaluations into high-risk episodes (like daily insulin injections)
- Training social workers to try and find available caregivers at the start of each episode
- Creating workflows that connect social worker notes with nursing and OASIS documentation
- Using their reports proactively in ADR prep and QAPI discussions
By making social workers part of the process early, agencies avoid scrambling to “prove” necessity after the fact. Instead, they have documentation that speaks for itself when an ADR comes in.
The best way to protect your agency against denied claims and ADRs, is to implement systems that keep your documentation airtight from day one. To learn more about the importance of compliance maintenance, check out the article below.
***Finally, a reminder: The strategies in this article aren’t a replacement for your clinical team’s judgment. Each patient must meet medical necessity, and every social worker visit must be justified and documented as such.
*Disclaimer: The content provided in this article is not intended to be, nor should it be construed as, legal, financial, or professional advice. No consultant-client relationship is established by engaging with this content. You should seek the advice of a qualified attorney, financial advisor, or other professional regarding any legal or business matters. The consultant assumes no liability for any actions taken based on the information provided.
Topics:
